Skip to main content

How Superhero comics teach information literacy Part 2

So we've talked about how superhero comes walk you through the process of recognizing citations and citing your sources and how the Easter eggs and references cause the reader to do research, now we're going to talk about a subject everyone knows and confronts regularly in research.. bias.

Comics, like most storytelling mediums, have a built in way to show bias. Some of this is from the obvious storytelling tricks of showing different perspectives. Comics like Marvels or Astro City do this rather well, taking the reader out of the typical head space of the superhero and into the world around them, those who look up and see the superheroes in their world and how that impacts them. These, however, are more subtle ways that the comics confront, show, and reveal the concept of bias to readers.

The most obvious tools that comics have are characters that are implicitly and strongly biased. For instance, Marvel has the infamous J. Jonah Jameson, who has a one man war against Spider-Man regardless of all the good he does. J. Jonah Jameson literally will not admit on any level that Spider-Man is a hero, even after Spider-Man has openly saved Jameson's life. Reading stories like this show children especially as they're growing up the power of bias and how even in the face of the truth, people can and do allow their bias to cloud their judgement and change the story.

Other recommendations for dealing with bias and perspective:

Any Lex Luthor story - There are several, but basically Lex sees Superman as an attack on the idea that humanity can raise themselves up.. because he's a God and he does it for them. It's an interesting line of thinking.. though obviously destructive.

Transmetropolitan - This is definitely for a adults/teens, but great book about journalism, seeing the world for how it is and using the power to shape public opinion but with facts, not just your opinions. It's honestly a great book.

Transformers Robots in Disguise/Optimus Prime & Transformers More than Meets the Eye/Lost Light - I've praised this series before, but it's really great about perspective and bias as if you don't know the whole concept of Transformers from the beginning is that there are two factions, the Autobots (aka the Good Guys) and the Decepticons (aka the Bad guys) and they are stuck in an eternal war for dominance and anyone unlucky to get caught in their path is destroyed. Robots in Disguise takes place after the war with the Autobots and Decepticons back on their home world Cybertron and trying to rebuild after a 4 million year war. It's a sticky mess as the factions no longer mean what they once did and we slowly discover, they may never have. More than Meets the Eye and it's follow up, Lost Light, follows a ragtag band of merry bots across the galaxy as they help, hurt, and search for a perfect past to help heal Cybertron. Again the decades long factions dissolve and change as the crew grows, adjusts, and even change some themselves. Finally Optimus Prime picks up from the end of Robots in Disguise as Optimus tries to bring Earth into the Council of Worlds as a colony of Cybertron. Things get even stickier here as Optimus balances his own team (made up of mostly new colonists), the Decepticons (who have come to Earth for a peaceful life), and humanity and all our baggage.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Comic books and age limits

Greetings, I have not posted anything in forever and for that I am very, very sorry. I just haven't had much to talk about.. but since this came up and it's bothering me, here we go. Comic books (particularly superhero comics) and age ranges/limits - Recently a fellow librarian asked for help on suggestions for tween comics. I named a few more recent ones that are for a kid/tween/teen demographic and then explained that most older comics would also be appropriate for this age group. At this age, I was reading New Teen Titans and Uncanny X-men for instance without any issues. I specifically stated that comics, particularly superhero comics, have largely been "all ages" for most of their history. This angered the librarian who I made the recommendations too. This librarian told me they specifically wanted TWEEN books because it was helpful for parents, tweens, and librarians and they needed to be TWEEN. Also that older books were too dated and the color and art wasn...

Katana at Super Hero High Review

I'm obviously addicted to DC Super Hero Girls. As I've said previously, I've pretty much consumed everything that is DC Super Hero Girls up until this point. So here's a review on the newest book, Katana at Super Hero High  by the always amazing and talented Lisa Yee. This is the 4th book in the series after Wonder Woman, Supergirl, and Batgirl all got their own books and this one is finally a breath of fresh air of newness. The first 3 books all focus on the concept of a new girl coming to school, struggling to fit in and accepting her place at this elite new school. There were slight variations on the theme, but that's basically it. Wonder Woman and Supergirl felt very similar as they both dealt with similar issues and Batgirl had slightly different perspective, but it still felt like we've tread over this material before. With Katana, we've finally got a new perspective. Katana is not the new girl at school, she's established with friends from the pre...

Pride Month Recommendations Part 1 Gay/bisexual male

I feel like I'm running behind on a lot of stuff right now, so there will probably be a few posts this week to make up for it. Sorry about that,. So June is typically considered Pride Month in the US, though local areas may have their own pride at different times. I'm going to start doing a series of posts on LGBTQIA comics that I recommend, but I'm going to do this a little differently. My idea is to break it down into parts, the first focusing on gay and bi men, then lesbians and bi women, then trans*, queer, intersex and asexual, then  finally circle back and focus on books that do a bit of all of them well (namely team books). I want to do it this way for a couple of reasons. First, while LGBTQIA is a community for various reasons, each individual group has it's own wants/needs/desires, so a book with a lesbian lead may not speak to an asexual teen as well as another book. The second reasons is to highlight some of the areas where comics as a medium are lacking ov...